Summary
The Supreme Court declined to hear a challenge to California’s requirement that some continuing medical education courses for doctors cover implicit bias. Justice Clarence Thomas, joined by Justice Samuel Alito, dissented and warned that the Ninth Circuit’s treatment of the instruction as government speech could weaken First Amendment protections for private speakers.Key Facts
- California requires licensed doctors to complete 50 hours of approved continuing medical education every two years.
- Qualifying courses involving patient care must include instruction about implicit bias and its effects on health outcomes.
- Physician Azadeh Khatibi and other challengers argued that the requirement compels private instructors to speak in violation of the First Amendment.
- The Ninth Circuit treated the instruction in the regulated courses as government speech.
- Thomas said the Ninth Circuit misapplied the Supreme Court’s framework for distinguishing government speech from private expression.
- The Supreme Court’s refusal to hear Khatibi v. Yip left the Ninth Circuit’s judgment in place without deciding the case on its merits.